<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><AQE.QER VERSION="2"><QUESTION QID="E-011908-15" AIDREF="AE-011908-15" LEG.VAL="WQ"><HEAD.Q><TI1><P.WQ>Question for written answer<NO.WQ QID="Q-E-011908-15">E-011908-15</NO.WQ></P.WQ><P.WQ>to the<DEST.WQ ORG="COM"> Commission</DEST.WQ></P.WQ></TI1><TI2><P.WQ>Rule 130</P.WQ><P.WQ><AUTHOR.WQ PERSID="29579">Marc Tarabella</AUTHOR.WQ><POL.GROUP GR="S&amp;D">(S&amp;D)</POL.GROUP></P.WQ></TI2><P.WQ><DATE.WQ DATE.DOC="20150724">(24 July 2015)</DATE.WQ></P.WQ></HEAD.Q><OBJ.Q OBJID="O-E-011908-15"><INT.OBJ.Q>Subject:</INT.OBJ.Q><TXT> Patentability of living organisms</TXT></OBJ.Q><CONTENTS CTNID="QC-E-011908-15"><P>On 25&#xa0;March&#xa0;2015, the Enlarged Board of Appeal of the European Patent Office (EPO) ruled that plants and plant material produced by essentially biological processes such as conventional crossbreeding and selection were henceforward patentable. </P><P>The ban on patenting plant varieties had already been undermined by the possibility of patenting of ‘plant material’ falling outside the very restrictive definition of ‘plant variety’ adopted by the Union for the Protection of New Varieties of Plants (UPOV) and in EU seed marketing directives. </P><P>The above EPO ruling has made it possible to the circumvent statutory restrictions imposed under Article&#xa0;53 of the European Patent Convention and Article&#xa0;4 of Directive&#xa0;98/44/EC, which stipulate that patents shall not be granted in respect of plant varieties and essentially biological processes, not to mention the European Parliament resolution on the patenting of essential biological processes<NOTE TYPE="NUM"><P><a href="#reds:iPlTa_Itm/TA-7-2012-0202" data-rel="reds" redmap-uri="/reds:iPlTa_Itm/TA-7-2012-0202/red:cycle_FNL" data-family="reds:iPlTa" data-version="FNL">P7_TA(2012)0202</a>.</P></NOTE>, which calls on the EPO to ‘exclude from patenting products derived from conventional breeding and all conventional breeding methods’. </P><P><P><NO.P>1.</NO.P>What view does the Commission take of these new developments and the resulting case-law?</P><P><NO.P>2.</NO.P>Does it intend to draft a new legislative proposal in a bid to remedy matters and will it seek to tighten up the relevant provisions so as to make them clearer and, above all, more restrictive?</P></P></CONTENTS></QUESTION></AQE.QER>