Plenary sitting

 

5.3.2014                                                                                                                  B7‑0229/2014

MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION

to wind up the debate on the statement by the Vice-President of the Commission / High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy

pursuant to Rule 110(2) of the Rules of Procedure

on the EU strategy for the Arctic

( 2013/2595(RSP) )

Véronique De Keyser, Libor Rouček, Liisa Jaakonsaari, Jens Nilsson, Ivari Padar

on behalf of the S&D Group

 

B7‑0229/2014

European Parliament resolution on the EU strategy for the Arctic

( 2013/2595(RSP) )

The European Parliament,

–       having regard to its previous resolutions on the Arctic, notably its resolution of 20 January 2011 on a sustainable EU policy for the High North[1], and to the European Economic Area Joint Parliamentary Committee Report of 28 October 2013 on Arctic Policy,

–       having regard to the joint communication of the Commission and of the High Representative of the Union for Foreign and Security Policy of 26 June 2012 entitled ‘Developing a European Union policy towards the Arctic region: progress since 2008 and next steps’, and to the accompanying staff working documents entitled ‘Inventory of activities in the framework of developing a European Union Arctic Policy’ ( SWD(2012)0182 ) and ‘Space and the Arctic’ ( SWD(2012)0183 ),

–       having regard to its oral question with debate of 9 April 2013 ( O-000042/2013 ).

–       having regard to the opinion of the European Economic and Social Committee on ‘EU Arctic Policy to address globally emerging interests in the region – a view of civil society’ of 17 April 2013,

–       having regard to the Arctic Council’s Kiruna Declaration of 15 May 2013,

–       having regard to the EU-Greenland Partnership 2007-2013 and to the Fisheries Partnership Agreement between the EU and Greenland, which entered into force on 1 January 2013 and is valid for a period of 3 years,

–       having regard to the EU’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme for the years 2014 to 2020,

–       having regard to the Arctic Council chairmanship programme, the Nordic Council of Ministers Arctic Cooperation Programme and the Barents Euro-Arctic Council (BEAC) programme,

–       having regard to the Declaration on the 20th Anniversary of the Barents Euro-Arctic Cooperation, issued in Kirkenes on 3-4 June 2013,

–       having regard to respective new and updated national strategies and policy papers concerning Arctic issues from Finland, Sweden, Denmark and Greenland, Norway, Russia, the USA and Canada, as well as Germany and the UK,

–       having regard to the statements adopted at the Northern Dimension Parliamentary Forum in Tromsø in February 2009 and February 2011,

–       having regard to the joint statement of the third ministerial meeting of the renewed Northern Dimension, held in Brussels on 18 February 2013,

–       having regard to the respective conference statements of the 9th Conference of Parliamentarians of the Arctic Region, held in Brussels from 13 to 15 September 2010, and of the 10th Conference of Parliamentarians of the Arctic Region, held in Akureyri from 5 to 7 September 2012,

–       having regard to the Nordic Council’s recommendations of 2012,

–       having regard to Directive 2013/30/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 10 June 2013 on the safety of offshore oil and gas operations[2],

–       having regard to its resolution of 20 April 2012 on ‘Our life insurance, our natural capital: an EU biodiversity strategy to 2020’[3],

–       having regard to its resolution of 5 February 2014 on a 2030 framework for climate and energy policies[4],

–       having regard to the judgments of the Court of Justice of the European Union of 3 October 2013 in Case C-583/11 P, and of 25 April 2013 in Case T-526/10, concerning the application for annulment of Commission Regulation (EU) No 737/2010 of 10 August 2010 laying down detailed rules for the implementation of Regulation (EC) 1007/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council on trade in seal products[5],

–       having regard to the World Trade Organisation (WTO) panel report of 25 November 2013 entitled ‘European Communities – measures prohibiting the importation and marketing of seal products’, chapter 1.3.5 (setting out the preliminary ruling issued on 29 January 2013), and to the EU’s notification of appeal to the WTO Appellate Body of 29 January 2014,

–       having regard to the Nordregio Report 2009:2 (‘Strong, Specific and Promising – Towards a Vision for the Northern Sparsely Populated Areas in 2020’),

–       having regard to Rule 110(2) of its Rules of Procedure,

A.     whereas the joint communication of the Commission and the High Representative of summer 2012 constitutes a further step forward;

B.     whereas Parliament, in its oral question for debate of 9 April 2013, challenged the Commission and Council to respond more specifically to the requests and conclusions contained in its resolution of 2011 on a sustainable EU policy for the High North and to come up with a clear policy vision, sectorial priorities and goals and concrete actions for the implementation of a comprehensive EU-Arctic strategy;

C.     whereas the Council has not yet published its conclusions on the Commission/EEAS joint communication of summer 2012;

D.     whereas Parliament has been an active participant in the work of the Standing Committee of Parliamentarians of the Arctic Region, through its Delegation for relations with Switzerland and Norway and to the EU-Iceland Joint Parliamentary Committee and the European Economic Area (EEA) Joint Parliamentary Committee;

E.     whereas Denmark, Finland and Sweden are Arctic countries and both Finland and Sweden are partially located within the Arctic Circle; whereas the EU’s only indigenous people, the Sami people, live in the Arctic regions of Finland and Sweden as well as in Norway and Russia;

F.     whereas Norway, as an engaged and reliable partner, is associated with the EU through the EEA and the Schengen Agreement;

G.     whereas the Arctic is an inhabited region with sovereign states; whereas the European Arctic region encompasses industrialised modern societies, rural areas and indigenous communities; whereas the active involvement of these regions in the development of the EU-Arctic policy is essential for ensuring legitimacy, mutual understanding and local support for the EU’s Arctic engagement;

H.     whereas there has been a longstanding engagement of the EU in the Arctic through its involvement in the Northern Dimension Policy with Russia, Norway and Iceland, in the Barents cooperation and particularly in the Barents Euro-Arctic Council and the Barents Regional Council, in the strategic partnerships with Canada, the US and Russia, and in its participation as an active ad hoc observer in the Arctic Council in recent years;

I.      whereas the Arctic Council made a decision in Kiruna on 15 May 2013 to ‘affirmatively receive’ the EU’s application for permanent observer status; whereas this affirmative decision includes the condition of resolving the seal products ban issue between the EU and Canada; whereas the EU and Canada are in the process of resolving this issue; whereas the EU is already working under the above status of permanent observer to the Arctic Council;

J.      whereas the EU and its Member States make a major contribution to research in the Arctic; whereas EU programmes, including the new Horizon 2020 Framework Programme, and the European structural and investment funds support major research projects in the region, benefiting not least the Arctic countries’ peoples and economies;

K.     whereas it is estimated that about a fifth of the world’s undiscovered hydrocarbon resources are located in the Arctic region, although more extensive research is needed to establish more accurately how much gas and oil there is to be found in which parts of the Arctic region and with what technology resources it could be extracted safely, whether exploitation could be pursued with fully satisfactory environmental and social guarantees for the local populations, and how economically and environmentally viable it would be to exploit these reserves; whereas, in this regard, it is also necessary to consider the safety of oil exploration and production and what impact these exploitations would have on the fragile ecosystem and biodiversity of the Arctic;

L.     whereas the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea provides the legal framework for managing Arctic Sea areas, including in areas beyond national jurisdiction;

M.    whereas the growing interest in the Arctic region of non-Arctic actors such as China, Japan, India and other Asian nations, their allocation of funding to polar research, and, not least, the confirmation of observer status to the Arctic Council for South Korea, China, Japan, India and Singapore, all indicate the increasing geopolitical importance of the Arctic on a global scale;

N.     whereas research and development, impact assessments and ecosystem protection have to accompany economic investment and development in order to ensure the sustainable development of the Arctic region;

O.     whereas reconciling prospective economic opportunities and interests with socio‑cultural, ecological and environmental challenges through sustainable development remains a top priority, reflected also in the national Arctic strategies of the Arctic states;

The EU and the Arctic

1.      Recalls the adoption of its resolution of 20 January 2011 on a sustainable EU policy for the High North, and welcomes the joint communication of the Commission and of the High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy of 26 June 2012; reaffirms its position that, with three EU Member States – Denmark, Finland and Sweden – being Arctic states, while Norway and Iceland are part of the EEA and Schengen, the EU has a legitimate interest by virtue of its rights and obligations under international law, its commitment to environmental, climate and other policies and its funding, research activities and economic interests, including shipping and the development of natural resources; recalls, moreover, that the EU has large Arctic land areas in Finland and Sweden that are inhabited by the only indigenous population group in the EU, the Sami;

2.      Recommends the creation of a mechanism for regular exchange and consultations on Arctic-related topics with regional, local and indigenous stakeholders of the European Arctic in order to facilitate mutual understanding;

3.      Takes note of the Kiruna Declaration of the Arctic Council in May 2013, and its decision on permanent observer status for the EU as well as other state entities; urges the Commission to follow up on the outstanding seal products ban issue with Canada and to duly inform Parliament regarding that process;

4.      Recalls the status of the EU and its Member States as active members of other Arctic‑relevant bodies such as the International Maritime Organisation (IMO); highlights the need to refocus the EU institutions’ activities on those fields where EU and EU Member States’ political, environmental or economic interests are concerned; emphasises, in particular, the need to bear in mind the EU and the European Arctic states’ and regions’ interests when utilising, amending or developing EU programmes or policies that do or can affect the Arctic, so that they serve the Arctic region as a whole;

5.      Regards the Barents Euro-Arctic Council (BEAC) as an important hub for cooperation between Denmark, Finland, Norway, Russia, Sweden and the Commission; notes the work of the BEAC in the fields of health, social issues, education, research, energy, culture, youth, SMEs and tourism; notes the advisory role of the Working Group of Indigenous Peoples (WGIP) within the BEAC;

6.      Recalls the contributions the EU is making to research and development and the engagement of economic actors registered and active under EU laws in the Arctic region;

7.      Asks the Commission to put forward proposals as to how the Galileo project or projects such as Global Monitoring for Environment and Security, which may have an impact on the Arctic, can be developed to enable safer and faster navigation in Arctic waters, thus investing in the safety and accessibility of the North-East Passage in particular, with a view to contributing to better predictability of ice movements, better mapping of the Arctic seabed and an understanding of the main geodynamic processes in the area;

8.      Emphasises the need for centres of competence for ensuring safety, emergency preparedness and rescue facilities; recommends that the EU actively contribute to the development of such centres;

9.      Welcomes the implementation of the Search and Rescue Agreement and the Oil Spill Response Agreement by Arctic Council members; regrets, however, that the agreement does not include specific binding common standards;

10.    Stresses the need for a binding instrument on oil pollution prevention;

11.    Highlights the need for an active engagement of the EU in all relevant working groups of the Arctic Council or relevant regional or international organisations such as the IMO and the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD);

12.    Welcomes the new Arctic Strategies recently published by EU Member States; hopes this will lead to more concrete engagements in the Arctic;

13.    Requests the Commission to develop closer cooperation with Iceland in fields of common interest such as the development of maritime transport and renewable energy, making full use of existing instruments and encouraging research and business cooperation between European and Icelandic actors, and thus ensuring that European interests do not suffer in this strategically important region;

14.    Welcomes the preparations for establishing an Arctic Business Council, to be attached to the Arctic Council in an advisory capacity, and highlights the percentage of European businesses and institutes contributing to and investing in the Arctic; suggests that there should be effective participation of business actors not only from the three Arctic EU Member States but also from other (observer) states, bearing in mind the global nature of many businesses today;

15.    Welcomes the work on bottom-up initiatives that can ensure a balanced and long-term engagement of European and non-European businesses, and asks the Commission to come forward with suggestions as to how to support European businesses engaging with sustainable and long-term balanced socio-economic development in the Arctic;

16.    Underlines the need for dialogue and partnership with the local and regional authorities in order to shape effective European investments for development and cooperation, and, in addition, to tackle future global challenges for progress in the Arctic and, not least, to make it possible to seize the full development potential of the area;

17.    Acknowledges the current gap between relevant competence on mineral extraction, processing and projected future needs as the region develops further; suggests that by participating in joint projects at European level, such as the Innovation Partnership on Raw Materials, Arctic actors can exchange information and competence across topics; emphasises that the EU must take into account the need for raw material activities to provide local benefits and enjoy local acceptance;

18.    Asks the Commission, in view of the huge number of scientific, economic and civic activities, in particular in the European Arctic, the Barents region and beyond, to develop practices aimed at better utilising existing EU funding and ensuring a proper balance in protecting and developing the Arctic region when channelling EU funds towards the Arctic;

19.    Further suggests the need to better align existing programmes (e.g. Interreg IV, the Northern Periphery Programme, the Kolarctic Programme, the Baltic Programme and the Blue Growth Strategy), as well as to contribute to funding Northern Dimension partnerships such as the Northern Dimension Environment Partnership and the Northern Dimension Partnership on Transport and Logistics, or ENPI envelopes, in order to enable an efficient channelling of funding, and to clearly define investment priorities for engagement with the Arctic region; suggests drawing up a Commission and EEAS platform to be in charge of ensuring a coherent channelling of funds for the Arctic;

20.    Reaffirms its support for, and urges the Commission to proceed with, the establishment of the EU Arctic Information Centre as a networked undertaking with a permanent office in Rovaniemi, in the framework of the Preparatory Action on the Strategic Environmental Impact Assessment of Development in the Arctic, as supported by the Commission and the EEAS in their joint communication of 2012 and implemented by the Arctic Centre of the University of Lapland, together with a network of European centres of excellence on the Arctic with the goal of achieving efficient access to Arctic information, dialogues at all levels, and communication in order to harness information and knowledge for sustainability in the Arctic;

21.    Awaits, in this regard, the results of the 18-months Preparatory Action (PA) project on the Strategic Environmental Impact Assessment of Development of the Arctic, to be published this spring; calls for the EU to proceed swiftly thereafter with the establishment of the EU Arctic Information Centre;

22.    Encourages the EU once more to intensify its efforts in bilateral diplomatic work with Arctic states in addition to the multilateral cooperation commitments;

23.    Suggests that there should be better coordination within the EU institutions between the Commission and the EEAS, particularly considering the cross-sectorial nature of the Arctic topics;

24.    Requests the Commission to develop and put forward a visionary, coherent and sustainable socio-economic and environmental strategy for the EU’s engagement in the Arctic, making sure that the interests of the EU and the European Arctic states and regions are taken into account whenever policies affecting the Arctic are developed, changed or updated;

25.    Emphasises the need for close alignment – also with regard to funding – between the EU-Arctic policy and its actions and the Northern Dimension (ND) policy with its partnerships; reminds the EU to safeguard sufficient financing of the efficient and successful ND policy;

26.    Underlines, in this respect, the significance of certain Arctic priorities, such as well‑functioning infrastructure and logistics, development in the Arctic region, encouraging investment in cold-climate expertise and relevant environment-friendly technologies, and support for regional and rural entrepreneurship and particularly for SMEs; calls for the EU to invest greater effort in integrating such Arctic priorities into its Europe 2020 strategy for growth and into programmes such as Horizon 2020 and Innovation Union, as well as into other Union research programmes;

27.    Stresses the vital importance of the EU regional and cohesion policy, the ENPI and the Interreg programme to this northernmost EU region, also with regard to interregional and cross-border cooperation;

28.    Calls on the EU to invest more in cooperation initiatives in the Arctic region, particularly with regard to the Northern Dimension Transport Partnership projects for linking the resource-rich Barents region to European markets;

29.    Requests the Commission to develop an Action Plan to define concrete steps for the coherent implementation of an EU-Arctic Strategy, as well as of existing Arctic-related policies and programmes, so as to ensure a coordinated approach when dealing with the Arctic region;

30.    Emphasises that an EU-Arctic Strategy requires the appropriate budget support to be made operational; requests the Commission to ensure that budget resources for Arctic actions and programmes are effectively coordinated with clear budget lines for the Arctic and a separate heading in the next EU budget, so as to ensure a credible implementation of the EU-Arctic Policy;

31.    Is still waiting for the Council’s conclusions on the Commission/EEAS joint communication of summer 2012;

Sustainable socio-economic development and mitigating and adapting to climate change in the Arctic region

32.    Recalls its resolution of 2011 and stresses the global impact of changes in the Arctic region and the important role that, besides the circumpolar nations, will be played by the EU and other industrial powers in reducing the pollution in the Arctic region caused by increasing activities there; points out that climate change in the Arctic will have a major impact on coastal regions in Europe and elsewhere and on climate-dependent sectors in Europe, such as agriculture and fisheries, energy, reindeer herding, hunting, tourism and transport;

33.    Underlines the importance of acknowledging the risks, as well as the full effects on the environment and ecosystem, when discussing prospecting for gas and oil in the Arctic; emphasises that the Arctic presents unique challenges to oil and gas drilling that should not be underestimated; acknowledges the current discussions between Arctic states about banning oil and gas drilling in certain areas of the Arctic;

34.    Believes that more information is needed on the Arctic marine ecosystems, the effects of climate change and the impacts that oil and gas drilling would have on the Arctic Ocean’s unique species, before continuing with prospecting for oil and gas in the Arctic; demands that before exploration and production drilling proceed in the Arctic, the institutions, organisations and agencies with relevant expertise must reassess the conditions under which future drilling might occur;

35.    Recalls the Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico and the need to take all necessary steps to ensure that a similar environmental catastrophe does not occur in EU waters;

36.    Recognises that the effects of melting ice and milder temperatures are not only creating the risk of displacing indigenous populations and thereby threatening the indigenous way of life, but are also creating opportunities for economic development in the Arctic region;

37.    Calls for the EU to make all possible efforts to ensure a sustainable reconciliation between economic activities and viable socio-ecological and environmental protection and development, in order to safeguard wellbeing within the Arctic and beyond;

38.    Stresses that maintaining developed and sustainable communities in the Arctic with a high quality of life is of the utmost importance, and that the EU can play a vital role in the matter; calls for the EU, in this respect, to intensify its work in the areas of ecosystem-based management, multilateral cooperation, knowledge-based decision‑making and close cooperation with local inhabitants and indigenous peoples;

39.    Acknowledges the wish of the inhabitants and governments of the Arctic region with sovereign rights and responsibilities to continue to pursue sustainable economic development while at the same time protecting the traditional sources of the indigenous peoples’ livelihood and the very sensitive nature of the Arctic ecosystems;

40.    Recognises that the waters around the North Pole are international waters;

41.    Regrets nevertheless, bearing in mind the similar legislation in the US, the effects which the EU regulation on the ban of seal products has produced for sections of the population, and in particular for indigenous culture and livelihood, resulting in an obstacle to EU engagement in the Arctic; urges the Commission, therefore, to explore ways to adapt or reform this legislation and make it compatible with the needs of the Union’s Arctic partners;

42.    Acknowledges the fundamental importance of the Regional Aid Guidelines (RAG), which enable regions in the Arctic with special characteristics and challenges to continue to use appropriate mechanisms to foster innovation and sustainable growth;

43.    Confirms its formulations on the rights of indigenous peoples in general, and the Sami as the EU’s only indigenous people in particular, and urges the Commission to further explore in what ways it could be ensured that their voice and experience are present in the EU policy-making processes; suggests, in this regard, supporting the establishment of an Independent Indigenous Representation in Brussels; stresses that policies for the positive development of living environments in the area also promote activities which take particular account of the prospects for the region’s indigenous peoples of developing their culture, language and customs, which may differ from those of the rest of the area’s society;

44.    Acknowledges that EU policies that strengthen higher education and research facilities in the area are fundamental for strengthening innovative environments and technology transfer mechanisms; underlines the importance of supporting the development of cooperation networks between higher education institutions within and beyond the region and providing opportunities for research funding, particularly in fields where the region has a proven track record, in order to bring about sustainable economic development in the regions in the Arctic;

45.    Underlines the major importance of the safety and security of new world trade routes by sea in the Arctic, in particular for the EU and its Member States’ economies, which control 40 % of world commercial shipping; welcomes the work being carried out within the International Maritime Organisation (IMO) on the finalisation of a mandatory Polar Code for shipping; urges the Member States and the Commission to engage in close contact with European research institutes and transport and insurance businesses, ensuring that new technologies and experiences are taken into account; emphasises that the EU and its Member States should actively uphold the freedom of the seas and the right to free passage through international waterways; encourages cooperation in both research and investment with a view to developing a robust and safe infrastructure for Arctic sea routes;

46.    Calls on states in the region to ensure that any current transport routes –and those that may emerge in the future – are open to international shipping and to refrain from introducing any unilateral arbitrary burdens, be they financial or administrative, that could hinder shipping in the Arctic, other than internationally agreed measures aimed at increasing security or protection of the environment;

47.    Notes the importance of developing infrastructure links connecting the Arctic region with the rest of Europe for future business developments to be successful; underlines, in particular, the importance of relevant TEN-T network links in the High North, such as links to the port of Narvik and the Bothnian corridor;

48.    Takes note of recent exploration activities in the European Arctic and the Barents Sea, and highlights the bilateral cooperation between Norway and Russia, aiming for application of the highest available technical standards in the field of environmental protection while prospecting for oil and gas in the Barents Sea; points out in particular the importance of the contentious development of new technologies, especially developed for the Arctic environment, such as sub-seabed installation technology;

49.    Recalls the position of the EU as a main consumer of Arctic natural gas, and highlights the role of natural gas from a safe and secure supply and produced according to the highest possible standards, as an important bridge element for the shift to a low-carbon economy in the future; supports the step-by-step precautionary approach in the development of energy resources in the Arctic, highlighting that the several regions of the Arctic differ substantially in their conditions and must therefore be dealt with separately;

50.    Recalls the right of the peoples of the Arctic to determine their own livelihoods, and recognises their wish for the sustainable development of the region; requests the Commission to report on which EU programmes could be utilised to support such a long-term and balanced sustainable development and to prepare means of contributing more concretely to realising this wish;

51.    Is of the opinion that in order to identify the specific potential of each locality and develop adequate development strategies with respect to regional differences, an inclusive process with the assistance of the national and EU levels is needed; believes that partnerships and dialogue between all levels of authority concerned can ensure that policies can be implemented at the most effective level;

52.    Takes note of the priorities of the new government of Greenland, and asks the Commission to explore how EU programmes could contribute to a sustainable development of Greenland, while also ensuring that the bonds with Denmark and with Europe as a whole can promote a development that is of long-term usefulness for both the people of Greenland and EU actors; urges both the Commission and the Member States to take a strategic view on the future of Greenland and the development of its resources, while ensuring proper European participation in order to contribute to a sustainable development of Greenland;

53.    Expresses its concern at the very limited success of the Commission Vice-President’s Letter of Intent signed with Greenland, compared to the speed of engagement and investment preparation by Asian nations; urges the Commission and the Member States also to coordinate with European business to ensure the EU’s long-term interests and the use of its capacity to contribute to long-term sustainable development;

54.    Instructs its President to forward this resolution to the Council, the Commission, the Vice-President / High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, the governments and parliaments of the Member States and the governments and parliaments of the Arctic region states.

[1] OJ C 136 E, 11.5.2012, p. 71.
[2] OJ L 178, 28.6.2013, p. 66.
[3] Texts adopted, P7_TA(2012)0146
[4] Texts adopted, P7_TA(2014)0094
[5] OJ L 216, 17.8.2010, p. 1.