Plenary sitting

 

B8‑0584/2016

9.5.2016

MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION

further to Questions for Oral Answer B8‑0367/2016 and B8‑0368/2016

pursuant to Rule 128(5) of the Rules of Procedure

on follow-up to the European Parliament resolution of 11 February 2015 on the US Senate report on the use of torture by the CIA

( 2016/2573(RSP) )

Monika Hohlmeier, Jeroen Lenaers

on behalf of the PPE Group

 

B8‑0584/2016

European Parliament resolution on follow-up to the European Parliament resolution of 11 February 2015 on the US Senate report on the use of torture by the CIA

( 2016/2573(RSP) )

The European Parliament,

–  having regard to the Treaty on European Union (TEU), in particular Articles 2, 3, 4, 6 and 21 thereof,

–  having regard to the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union,

–  having regard to the European Convention on Human Rights and the protocols thereto,

–  having regard to the relevant UN human rights instruments, in particular the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights of 16 December 1966, the Convention against Torture and other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment of 10 December 1984 and the relevant protocols thereto, and the International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance of 20 December 2006,

–  having regard to the Guidelines to EU Policy Towards Third Countries on Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment and to the EU Guidelines on the Death Penalty,

–  having regard to the UN Human Rights Council report of the Special Rapporteur on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, focusing on commissions of inquiry in response to patterns or practices of torture or other forms of ill-treatment[1],

–  having regard to the US-EU Joint Statement on Closure of Guantánamo Bay and Future Counterterrorism Cooperation of 15 June 2009,

–  having regard to the European Court of Human Rights judgments in cases Nasr and Ghali v Italy (Abu Omar) of February 2016, Al-Nashiri v Poland and Husayn (Abu Zubaydah) v Poland of July 2014, and El-Masri v the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia of December 2012,

–  having regard to UN Security Council resolution 2178 (2014) of 24 September 2014 on the threats to international peace and security caused by terrorist acts,

–  having regard to its resolutions of 14 February 2007[2] and 19 February 2009[3] on the alleged use of European countries by the CIA for the transportation and illegal detention of prisoners,

–  having regard to its resolution of 11 September 2012 on alleged transportation and illegal detention of prisoners in European countries by the CIA: follow-up of the European Parliament TDIP Committee report[4],

–  having regard to President Obama’s Executive Order 13491 of 22 January 2009 on ensuring lawful interrogations,

–  having regard to President Obama’s State of the Union address of 20 January 2015,

–  having regard to its plenary debate of 17 December 2014 on the US Senate report on the use of torture by the CIA,

–  having regard to its resolution of 11 February 2015 on the US Senate report on the use of torture by the CIA[5],

–  having regard to the parliamentary fact-finding mission of its Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs to Bucharest, Romania of 24 and 25 September 2015, and to the corresponding mission report,

–  having regard to the public hearing held by its Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs on 13 October 2015 on ‘Investigation of alleged transportation and illegal detention of prisoners in European countries by the CIA’,

–  having regard to the publication of the 2015 study for its Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs entitled ‘A quest for accountability? EU and Member State inquiries into the CIA Rendition and Secret Detention Programme’,

–  having regard to the closed inquiry pursuant to Article 52 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) considering illegal CIA detentions and transport of detainees suspected of terrorist acts, and to the request of the Secretary-General of the Council of Europe to all States Parties to the ECHR to provide him with information on past or ongoing investigations, relevant cases before domestic courts or other measures taken with regard to the matter of this inquiry by 30 September 2015[6],

–  having regard to the questions to the Council and to the Commission on follow-up to the European Parliament resolution of 11 February 2015 on the US Senate report on the use of torture by the CIA ( O-000038/2016 – B8‑0367/2016 and O-000039/2016 – B8‑0368/2016 ),

–  having regard to the motion for a resolution of the Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs,

–  having regard to Rules 128(5) and 123(2) of its Rules of Procedure,

A.  whereas the EU is founded on a commitment to democracy, the rule of law, human rights and fundamental freedoms, respect for human dignity and international law, not only in its internal policies but also in its external dimension; whereas the EU’s commitment to human rights, as reinforced by the entry into force of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights and the process of accession to the European Convention on Human Rights, must be reflected in all policy areas in order to make the EU’s human rights policy effective;

B.  whereas Parliament has repeatedly called for the fight against terrorism to respect human dignity, human rights and fundamental freedoms, including in the context of international cooperation in this field, on the basis of the EU Treaties, the European Convention on Human Rights, national constitutions and fundamental rights legislation;

C.  whereas Parliament has strongly condemned the US-led Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) rendition and secret detention programme involving multiple human rights violations, including unlawful and arbitrary detention, torture and other ill-treatment, as an outcome of the work of its Temporary Committee on the alleged use of European countries by the CIA for the transportation and illegal detention of prisoners;

D.  whereas a proper accountability process is essential in order to preserve citizens’ trust in democratic institutions, to protect and promote human rights effectively in the EU’s internal and external policies, and to ensure legitimate and effective security policies based on the rule of law;

E.  whereas on 11 September 2001 the United States came under unprecedented attacks from al‑Qaeda terrorists, which claimed the lives of more than 3 000 people, when planes were flown into the twin towers of the World Trade Centre, the Pentagon and a field in Pennsylvania;

F.  whereas EU-US relations are based on a strong partnership and cooperation in many fields, on the basis of their common shared values of democracy, the rule of law and fundamental rights; whereas the EU and the USA have strengthened their engagement in the fight against terrorism since the terrorist attacks of 11 September 2001;

G.  whereas on 15 June 2009 the EU and its Member States and the USA signed a joint statement on the closure of the Guantánamo Bay detention facility and future counterterrorism cooperation, based on shared values, international law and respect for the rule of law and human rights;

H.  whereas the assistance of EU Member States in resettling some of the prisoners has been slow and limited;

I.  whereas on 23 February 2016 President Obama sent Congress a plan to close once and for all the US military prison at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba;

J.  whereas on 3 December 2014, after six years of investigations, the US Senate Select Committee on Intelligence released an executive summary of its study of the CIA’s Detention and Interrogation Programme;

K.  whereas in the light of this executive summary Parliament instructed its Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs, its Committee on Foreign Affairs and its Subcommittee on Human Rights to resume their investigations into the alleged transportation and illegal detention of prisoners in EU countries by the CIA and to report to plenary within a year;

L.  whereas this follow-up inquiry entailed the sending of a parliamentary fact-finding mission to Romania, where secret CIA detention sites allegedly existed, the gathering of all relevant information and evidence on possible bribes or other acts of corruption linked to the CIA programme, and the organisation of a hearing involving national parliaments and practitioners in order to take stock of all past and ongoing parliamentary and judicial inquiries;

1.  Reiterates its strong condemnation of the use of enhanced interrogation techniques, which are prohibited under international law and which breach, inter alia, the rights to liberty, security, humane treatment, freedom from torture, presumption of innocence, fair trial, legal counsel and equal protection under the law;

2.  Considers that the Member States have stated their willingness to abide by international law; stresses, consequently, that Member States conducting independent and effective inquiries on human rights violations connected with the CIA programme must base their investigations on solid judicial evidence and on respect for national judicial systems and EU law, not just on media and public speculation;

3.  Underlines the unique importance and the strategic nature of the transatlantic relationship at a time of rising global instability; takes the view that this relationship, which is based on common interests as well as shared values, needs to be further strengthened on the basis of respect for multilateralism, the international rule of law and negotiated conflict resolution;

4.  Recalls the USA’s crucial role in fighting terrorism, including within Europe; believes that transatlantic cooperation on counterterrorism needs to be preserved for the shared benefit of citizens on both sides of the Atlantic and in full respect of fundamental human rights and privacy, as guaranteed by EU legislation; calls for continued political dialogue between the transatlantic partners on security and counterterrorism matters, including the protection of civil and human rights, in order to combat terrorism effectively;

5.  Underlines the fact that transatlantic cooperation based on common values such as the promotion of freedom and security, democracy and fundamental human rights is, and must be, a key priority in EU foreign relations; reiterates the clear position taken in the US-EU statement of 2009 to the effect that joint efforts to combat terrorism must comply with obligations under international law, in particular international human rights law and humanitarian law, and that this will make our countries stronger and more secure;

6.  Reiterates its decisive commitment to cooperating with the USA in the global fight against terrorism, while ensuring full and strict compliance with fundamental rights and rule-of-law obligations, and further stresses that effective counterterrorism measures and respect for human rights are not contradictory, but are complementary and mutually reinforcing aims; points out that respect for fundamental rights is an essential element in successful counterterrorism policies; recalls that the fight against terrorism requires a multilateral approach, and therefore actively promotes a global alliance against terrorism within the United Nations, involving all international actors;

7.  Welcomes the recent positive steps taken by President Obama in his continuing and repeated efforts to close the detention facility at the US military base in Guantánamo Bay, Cuba, and to provide for the release of those detainees who have not been charged; stresses that President Obama, in his State of the Union address of 20 January 2015, reiterated his determination to fulfil his 2008 campaign pledge to close down the Guantánamo Bay prison, and further welcomes the plan he sent to Congress on 23 February 2016; further calls for all remaining detainees to be transferred to regular mainland detention facilities under conditions that comply with international standards, and to be legitimately charged and prosecuted before ordinary courts;

8.  Calls for the regular, structured EU-US interparliamentary dialogue, in particular between the European Parliament Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs and its relevant counterparts in the US Congress and Senate, to be reinforced by using all the avenues of cooperation and dialogue provided by the Transatlantic Legislators’ Dialogue (TLD); welcomes, in this connection, the 78th meeting of the TLD between the European Parliament and the US Congress, to be held in The Hague on 26-28 June 2016, as an opportunity to reinforce that cooperation, given that counterterrorism cooperation will be an integral part of the discussion;

9.  Calls on the Member States, in the light of the increased cooperation and exchange of information between their secret intelligence and security agencies, to ensure full democratic scrutiny of those agencies and their activities through appropriate internal, executive, judicial and independent parliamentary oversight;

10.  Recalls that national parliaments, in their functions of scrutiny of the executive, and national and European courts, in particular the European Court of Human Rights, as guardians of the rule of law and the protection of citizens’ fundamental rights, are the bodies best suited to carry out any investigation into, and criminal proceedings relating to, the alleged transportation and illegal detention of prisoners in EU countries by the CIA, and to provide effective remedies for victims;

11.  Notes that on 11 February 2016 the Secretary-General of the Council of Europe, Thorbjørn Jagland, decided to close the 10-year inquiry begun by his predecessor under Article 52 of the European Convention on Human Rights into illegal CIA detentions and transport of detainees suspected of terrorist acts; notes that, while not all national replies were substantial, the procedure nonetheless yielded information which has subsequently been used in Council of Europe actions to identify and remedy the violations concerned;

12.  Stresses that the one-year investigation by Parliament’s Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs into the alleged transportation and illegal detention of prisoners in EU countries by the CIA has not led to any significant additional conclusions, and therefore instructs it to close its inquiry, as the Council of Europe did on 11 February 2016;

13.  Instructs its President to forward this resolution to the Commission, the Council and the national parliaments.

[1] A/HRC/19/61, 18.1.2012.
[2] OJ C 287 E, 29.11.2007, p. 309.
[3] OJ C 76 E, 25.3.2010, p. 51.
[4] OJ C 353 E, 3.12.2013, p. 1.
[5] Texts adopted, P8_TA(2015)0031
[6] http://website-pace.net/documents/19838/2008330/AS-JUR-INF-2016-06-EN.pdf/f9280767-bf73-44a1-8541-03204e2dfae3