Plenary sitting
4.7.2016
MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION
to wind up the debate on the statement by the Commission
pursuant to Rule 37(3) of the Rules of Procedure and the Framework Agreement on relations between the European Parliament and the Commission
on the strategic priorities for the Commission Work Programme 2017
( 2016/2773(RSP) )
Bas Eickhout
on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group
European Parliament resolution on Resolution of the European Parliament on the strategic priorities for the Commission Work Programme 2017
( 2016/2773(RSP) )
The European Parliament,
– having regard to the Political Guidelines for the European Commission, entitled ‘A New Start for Europe: My Agenda for Jobs, Growth, Fairness and Democratic Change’ and presented by Jean-Claude Juncker on 15 July 2014,
– having regard to the Commission communication entitled ‘Commission Work Programme 2016 – No time for business as usual’ ( COM(2015)0610 ), and Annexes 1 to 6 thereto,
– having regard to the Conference of Committee Chairs’ Summary Report, which provides complementary input to this resolution from the point of view of parliamentary committees and which the Commission should take duly into account when drafting and adopting its Work Programme for 2017,
– having regard to its resolution of 28 June 2016 on the decision to leave the EU resulting from the UK referendum[1],
– having regard to the European Council conclusions of 28-29 June 2016,
– having regard to the contribution of the Committee of the Regions to the Commission’s 2017 Work Programme,
– having regard to Rule 37(3) of its Rules of Procedure,
Introduction
A. whereas the European integration process has brought peace and contributed to security and prosperity in Europe over decades; whereas the outcomes of this last decade’s democratic consultations must be seen as an opportunity to reflect on our common European project, its actual benefits, current shortcomings and renewed purpose;
B. whereas the consequences of globalisation are increasingly stirring anxieties and Euroscepticism among EU citizens; whereas the EU should provide reassurance and protection against these consequences;
C. whereas it is no longer possible to allow European integration to be reduced to a mere economic project and steps must be taken, as a matter of urgency, to win back the hearts of Europeans in favour of the European project, with a serious change of course in EU policies;
D. whereas, in spite of its own shortcomings, Parliament has a particular responsibility in the definition of our common European interest and should contribute to overcoming the current divisions in the Council, whose work is too often stalled by national haggles and ‘zero-sum game’ mentalities;
E. whereas the general interest of Europeans should always prevail over the defence of national or corporate interests;
F. whereas as Europeans, we have chosen a common future, as a true community based on shared values and objectives; whereas local, regional and national identities are not mutually exclusive and contribute to our broader European identity;
G. whereas the current cumulated crises require genuine European solutions; whereas we want Europe to play its role and take its responsibilities on the international stage, committed to solidarity, multilateralism and our external partnerships, and promoting global convergence towards higher standards; whereas we want to secure our common project of shared peace, prosperity and democracy, with a view to creating an appealing future for all generations;
Improving the working and living conditions of European citizens
1. Recalls that Europe’s current economic recovery is modest and unbalanced, with many regions of the Union still experiencing unacceptable levels of unemployment, poverty, inequality and a severe lack of prospects for younger generations; insists, therefore, that the EU’s core economic and social agenda must include measures aimed at reducing social inequalities and promoting gender equality and quality jobs for all, while stepping up investments in the education system;
2. Calls on the Commission to put forward legislative proposals to underpin its initiative on the Pillar of Social Rights and calls on it, in this context, to work towards a ‘social protection floor’, in order to ensure that European citizens enjoy an adequate minimum level of social protection and services of general interest, including public services, so that people can live in dignity and actively participate in society throughout their lives ( this should include access to affordable housing, access to adequate health care, a right to child care, minimum standards for income security, including pensions, or equivalent minimum social protection);
3. Calls for the introduction of a ‘social veto right’, or any mechanism that can prevent EU legislation from coming into force where its impact is likely to damage the poorest sections of society, increase social and gender inequalities or decrease social rights;
4. Calls on the Commission to concretely deliver on its repeated promises to establish a ‘social Europe’, firstly by reforming the EMU and with further initiatives to:
– develop and promote social investment in adequate social protection and in accessible, affordable, conveniently located and high-quality education and social, health and care services, in order to reduce social inequalities and combat poverty, and in particular to reduce child poverty;
– close the skills gap and ensure access to quality education, training and lifelong learning for all;
– promote quality jobs for everyone, paying particular attention to young people and the long-term unemployed;
– promote health and safety at work through ongoing revision of the relevant directives;
– uphold the principle of non-discrimination for all workers, including mobile and posted workers, and ensure that they are provided with adequate pay so that they can live a decent life at their place of residence;
– address the gender gap in pay and pensions and work-life balance challenges, including through the adoption of ambitious proposals for a maternity leave directive and a carer’s leave directive and through the provision of full-day early childhood education and care, in particular to ensure that women and men are equal carers and equal earners and to enhance women’s participation in the labour market;
5. Calls on the Commission to monitor, encourage and support Member States’ efficient and effective spending of funds to fight poverty and social exclusion and to boost youth employment and quality job creation, in particular in regions with high unemployment levels, through programmes financed by the Youth Employment Initiative (YEI), the European Structural and Investment Funds (ESIF), the European Fund for Strategic Investments (EFSI) and the EIB;
Strengthening economic recovery and long-term competitiveness with a view to creating jobs, raising living standards and generating prosperity
6. Considers that economic models based solely on GDP growth and continuous over-exploitation of natural resources and financialisation have reached their limits; considers that, henceforth, the EU needs to make sustainability the core of any sound, future-oriented and crisis-solving economic policy; considers the defence of established market positions as a potential hindrance on the path towards a new economic model;
7. Calls on the Commission to develop an overarching Sustainable Development Strategy for the period up to 2030 and a specific implementation plan; considers that the EU must ensure that it does not cherry-pick the easiest or preferred goals and must go beyond policy-as-usual by aiming for the highest level of ambition in all targets, guaranteeing that no-one is left behind and that planetary boundaries are fully respected; considers it necessary, to this end, to avoid further degradation and loss of biodiversity and achieve restoration of degraded ecosystems;
8. Asks the Commission to design a new ambitious and comprehensive socially and environmentally sustainable industrial strategy in addition to the circular economy package; considers that additional public and private investments are needed that must focus on energy transition, eco-innovative SMEs, research and education;
9. Highlights that, in the context of a dangerous global race for resources the European economy must, in order to remain competitive, become sustainable and ‘go digital’; calls for the Europe 2020 strategy to be put at the centre of the EU’s economic decisions;
10. Asks the Commission to monitor, encourage and support Member States’ actions to guarantee that competition remains fair and that citizens, consumers and workers benefit therefrom;
11. Calls for sustainability, public health, consumer protection and workers’ welfare to be at the heart of any further economic reforms, in particular with regard to the Common Agricultural Policy, which should become a comprehensive ‘food and sustainable rural environment policy’;
12. Calls on the Commission to propose more measures to foster research and development, innovation, cultural diversity and creativity as central engines of job creation and to take account of the fact that companies’ and notably SMEs’ access to capital is a vital means of encouraging the development and production of new products and services in both traditional and emerging sectors;
13. Reminds the Commission that fundamental economic and technological choices, such as genetic modification, nanotechnologies and nuclear energy, must follow the precautionary principle and be submitted to full democratic and transparent scrutiny and process, as promised time and again by the Commission’s President on the issue of GMOs and as expected by citizens;
Responding to climate change and ensuring energy security
14. Recalls that efforts must be stepped up to achieve the Energy Union, that will guarantee energy security and affordable and sustainable energy for all citizens and businesses;
15. Notes the human and economic consequences of climate disasters in Europe and worldwide; highlights the importance of continuing to address the root causes of climate change, in particular in the transport sector, while securing the competitiveness of our industry, with an ambitious climate strategy, including energy efficiency;
16. Calls for more ambitious targets to be set at EU level for greenhouse gas reductions and renewables and energy efficiency for the post-2020 period, in line with the Paris COP 21 Agreement;
17. Asks the Commission to develop a common strategy for energy and climate diplomacy that will address these global concerns, and for the EU to play a more active role in the global promotion of renewable energy use, as a key means of tackling climate change;
18. Urges the Commission to stop subsidising fossil fuel from EU funds and to coordinate the efforts of the Member States towards a swift phase-out of national fossil subsidies; asks the Commission also to ensure that no national or EU subsidies are used for the financing of new nuclear reactors and to urge the Member States to abandon plans for the life-time extension of nuclear power plants;
Ensuring a consistent response to the increased inflow of refugees
19. Is of the opinion that the EU must work out concrete solutions to address the refugee arrivals, in particular by addressing their root causes, through holistic policy responses that encompass policy coherence for development, trade, climate and investment policies, while ensuring safe and regular access for those seeking international protection;
20. Is disappointed by the lack of solidarity between Member States in their response to the increased inflow of refugees; calls for the swift implementation of the decision to relocate 160 000 refugees from Italy and Greece to other Member States and for the setting-up of a European search and rescue programme; expresses grave concerns at the legality, suitability and human rights compatibility of the informal international agreements concluded with third countries with the aim of making development cooperation conditional upon security and border control policies that result in the criminalisation and stigmatisation of refugees and migrants;
21. Is of the opinion that resettlement should be preserved as one of the durable solutions to refugee displacement and as an unconditional instrument of international solidarity; calls for the creation of increased resettlement opportunities to enable the resettlement of at least 500 000 refugees per year from the countries of origin and transit, which, if they were properly distributed, would result in entirely manageable numbers for the EU;
22. Calls for a reform of the current Dublin asylum system, with a new system based on a fair allocation of asylum seekers between Member States, with objective criteria and built around asylum seekers’ existing ties with and preferences for a certain Member State; believes that this system should be binding on all Member States and based on incentives rather than coercive measures;
23. Calls for the creation of regular migration channels, which should entail, in line with the suggestions of the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights, humanitarian admission, including for climate refugees and human rights defenders, temporary protection, family reunification, economic admissions at varying skills levels, including for workers in low-wage sectors and job seekers, student mobility and medical evacuation;
24. Calls for conditions to be created within the EU for well-managed reception of asylum-seekers that ensures their safety and humane and dignified treatment, with particular attention to the needs of women, girls, LGBTI people and other vulnerable groups; points out, at the same time, that sufficient resources must be guaranteed for education and labour market integration and social inclusion of both refugees and migrants;
25. Calls on the Commission to establish a visa regime for human rights defenders at risk in third countries;
Addressing the security concerns of citizens
26. Reiterates that putting in place mostly symbolic repressive, mass surveillance and border control measures which threaten civil liberties, fundamental rights and the principle of free movement is not the right answer;
27. Warns against speedy adoption of laws on terrorism, as an emotional reaction, that can have adverse effects on the freedoms and fundamental rights of suspects and innocent citizens; calls on the Commission to provide a detailed impact assessment for each measure which could potentially infringe on the rights of EU citizens and residents;
28. Stresses that internal and external security are increasingly linked; recalls that this should not lead to the application of foreign policy instruments in the internal security context; reiterates that internal security and counter terrorism measures and the prosecution of terrorist suspects are the sole task and responsibility of police and judicial authorities and must take place in full compliance with stringent procedural safeguards and criminal law provisions;
29. Reiterates the importance of the Schengen area of free movement; underlines the need for the effective management of the external borders, based on human rights and full respect for international and EU law;
30. Calls on the Commission, in order to address the threats of terrorism and violent extremism, to monitor closely the transposition and implementation of EU criminal procedure law standards and counter-terrorism measures including education and prevention, effective police and judicial cooperation, timely sharing of information between national authorities and through Europol and Eurojust, and measures to tackle emerging trends in terrorism financing; reiterates the need for better equipment and resourcing of Joint Investigation Teams in the framework of Europol and Eurojust;
31. Calls on the Commission to present a White Paper on the concept of ‘European internal security’ as a legal basis for any future security measure, taking into account freedom of movement and the lack of internal border controls, and which is separate from the concept of ‘national security’ , which Member States invoke in the fight against crime and terrorism; calls for a coherent definition of what is ‘national security’ and what does not fall within its scope; rejects the use of national security and ‘state secrets’ as a pretext to undermine fundamental rights, such as lawyer-client confidentiality;
32. Calls on the Commission to mobilise expertise and technical and financial resources in order to ensure EU-level coordination and exchanges of best practice in the fight against violent extremism and terrorist propaganda, radical networks and recruitment by terrorist organisation; underlines that repressive measures may only be effective if coupled with long-term prevention, integration and reintegration, and non-discrimination policy strategies;
33. Urges the Commission and the Member States to conduct a full review of all security legislation that has already been adopted and, on that basis, to ensure that it is withdrawn or implemented, as appropriate; reiterates its call for an in-depth evaluation of the EU counter-terrorism strategy, which should assess the application of the adopted measures, their cost and their effectiveness; expects the Commission to update the security agenda as necessary in light of the lack of cooperation between Member States with regard to the effective combating of organised crime and terrorism;
34. Calls on the Commission to present its announced proposals for a proper legal base for the European Counter-Terrorism Centre within Europol, its proposals to improve and develop existing information systems with regard to interoperability, effectiveness and proportionality, address information gaps and move towards interoperability, and its proposals for compulsory information-sharing at EU level about suspicions and risks in this field between Member States, accompanied by stringent and consistent data protection safeguards in all police and justice frameworks;
35. Calls on the Commission to put forward a legislative initiative on combating all forms of violence against women and gender-based violence; calls on the Commission to swiftly complete the EU’s accession to the Council of Europe´s Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence (Istanbul Convention), as repeatedly called for by Parliament;
Deploying an ambitious external action agenda: on neighbourhood and on the global system
36. Calls for an ambitious implementation of the new EU Global Strategy, positioning the EU as an effective promoter of its core values, principles and norms in a rapidly changing world and expects the Commission and the European External Action Service to mobilise all EU external action instruments in a coherent manner in order to achieve improved rules-based global governance, wide convergence on better standards, lasting peace, improved security and stronger respect for human rights, democracy, the rule of law and fundamental freedoms in the world; stresses, to that end, that the following key elements should be moved to the top of the EU’s external affairs agenda:
– Demanding that the EU and the Member States reverse the current tendency of trading away human rights standards for short-term commercial, security and energy-supply interests;
– Promoting stability and prosperity in the EU’s neighbourhood, through initiatives fostering development, democracy, cultural cooperation, good governance and the rule of law, by enhancing civilian conflict prevention and reconciliation measures, the strengthening of transparency, accountability, parliamentary oversight and democratic control over the security sector as well as assisting the Vice-President of the Commission / High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy (VP/HR) and the Member States in their peace-keeping and peace-enforcement efforts in the context of the Common Security and Defence Policy;
– Assisting the VP/HR and the Member States to ensure that the Common Security and Defence Policy becomes a more effective policy which is coherent and consistent with other EU external policies such as development aid and civilian conflict prevention under the Instrument contributing to Stability and Peace, and which ensures security, peace, stability, democracy and human rights and strengthens adherence to the principles of the UN Charter; ensuring that structures, mechanisms or tools that already exist become an operational reality;
– Urging the Commission and the VP/HR to step up compliance with the EU Common Position on Arms Exports by Member States and to make sure that legislation regulating the export of dual-use technologies prevents the transfer of mass surveillance and tracking to non-democratic countries;
– Urging the Commission to report on the effectiveness of the pilot project on defence research and its related cooperation with the European Defence Agency; calls on the Commission to withdraw plans to launch an EUR 80 million preparatory action on defence research as a follow-up measure, given that recent European Defence Agency data has also confirmed that Member States are unwilling and unable to cooperate in the field of defence research and development; rejects any attempts to use EU budget resources for military research and development;
– Moving much faster forward the enlargement negotiation process by strengthening social, political and economic stability, environmental sustainability and democracy in the candidate countries, without watering down fundamental accession criteria;
– Making development cooperation policy more effective and improving its coordination and coherence with other EU external action instruments; ensuring coherence and consistency between development, civilian conflict prevention and civilian security policies as they are all interlinked, interdependent and mutually reinforcing;
– Integrating the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and Policy Coherence for Development (PCD) in the EU’s external and internal policies;
– Taking stronger, more effective, convincing and coherent initiatives as regards the resolution of the conflicts in the EU’s neighbourhood and making available all the instruments at the EU’s disposal;
– Rejecting Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA), the Trade in Services Agreement (TiSA) and the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP), and noting that European citizens and Parliament are increasingly critical of the actual impacts of free-trade agreements, as they can also have undesired impacts on employment, competitiveness and EU human rights and sustainable development standards; demands that the Union’s trade defence instruments be modernised and trade policies be designed in coherence with the EU development goals, climate targets, environmental priorities and social and human rights standards;
Fair taxation policies for adequate resources
37. Stresses that there has never been a more urgent need to step up the fight against tax evasion and tax avoidance, which represents potential income to national budgets of up to EUR 1 trillion; considers that these resources could have been spent on investing in the future, boosting employment and reducing inequalities;
38. Calls on the Commission to act without delay to ensure that profits are taxed in countries where the actual economic activity and value are created in Europe; considers that the EU should work towards a mandatory common consolidated corporate tax base (CCCTB), step up efforts to investigate tax-related state aid breaches, apply common rules on the use and transparency of tax rulings and pursue a determined common approach to close down tax havens;
39. Calls on the Commission to include in its fight against tax evasion and tax avoidance a gender dimension and an external dimension, including as regards profits that leave the EU without being taxed;
40. Calls for a financial transaction tax which will force the financial sector to pay its fair share to deal with the crisis which it caused, to curb unproductive short-term speculative activities and to raise additional revenues in response to the present social, environmental and economic challenges; deplores the weakening of the original Commission proposal and considers that it should instead be extended to currency transactions as proposed by Parliament and implemented by mid-2017 at the latest;
Strengthening the EU budget and financial instruments
41. Is of the opinion that, in order to act effectively, the EU needs a new financial and fiscal strategy; considers that the Commission should, to this end, propose measures based on the following principles and elements:
– Mobilising adequate resources swiftly, given that there is no avoiding the need to reform the system for financing the Union by strengthening genuine own resources or introducing new resources in order to make the Union budget more stable, more sustainable and more predictable; at the same time, it is important to respect the principle of universality and to improve transparency;
– Start implementing as a matter of priority the principles of gender budgeting;
– For maximum results, EU budgetary instruments need to be managed with close attention to performance and cost-effectiveness, while ensuring compliance and protecting EU financial interests;
– The EU should take steps to provide resources for responding to the challenges of high youth and long-term unemployment and the internal and external dimensions of the refugee emergency;
– After only two years of implementation, the multiannual financial framework (MFF) has reached its limits; furthermore, without a comprehensive mid-term revision of the multiannual financial framework, the EU budget will be unable to address additional financial needs and new political priorities, and unable to avoid the resurgence of a payment crisis; a full-fledged ‘post-electoral revision’ of the MFF, and not just a technical review, must be carried out as a way to mobilise the EU budget and thus contribute to the recovery of the European economy, ensuring the success of the Europe 2020 Strategy, supporting the EU’s post-2015 international commitments and dealing structurally with the growing payment problem;
– The EFSI needs to be reformed in order to enable all Member States to undertake higher levels of strategic investment, to better target regions where investment is most desperately needed and to ensure that public funding for investment is contributing to the transition to a sustainable economy; additional funding should be considered, rather than diverting existing EU funds, such as Horizon 2020 or the Connecting Europe Facility (CEF), towards other funds or new investment instruments;
– Effective implementation of cohesion policy for 2014-20 should be accompanied by preparations for its post-2020 phase, respecting its true nature as set out in the Treaties, its importance as an investment tool for all regions in the EU and as an expression of European solidarity; resources from cohesion policy should be further used to shift towards a low-carbon economy with a view to contributing to the COP21 Paris agreement and supporting efforts for reception of refugees and migrants, including their inclusion, and any reduction in the cohesion policy budget should be avoided;
Completing the Economic and Monetary Union
42. Insists on respecting the requirements in Union law regarding democratic accountability for decisions in the context of European economic governance;
43. Insists that the EU must work towards upward convergence as regards economic, social and resource indicators; considers that the economic governance framework should be reformed to this end;
44. Believes that the EU must improve the credibility, consistency, national ownership, democratic legitimacy, sustainability, gender and social dimension of the existing economic governance framework by introducing simpler, countercyclical and transparent rules, avoiding moral hazard, ensuring a symmetric correction of macro-economic imbalances and incentivising public investment;
45. Calls for closer economic policy coordination to address the eurozone’s investment gaps and strengthen reform efforts in order to increase productivity, overall resource efficiency and to sustain demand;
46. Considers that the banking union needs to be completed, with risk-reduction measures going hand in hand with risk-sharing;
47. Points out that an EMU fiscal capacity should urgently be developed to make the EMU resistant to symmetric and asymmetric shocks and to tackle unacceptable levels of unemployment in many regions of the EMU;
48. Asks the Commission to urgently explore ways of using common financial tools to tackle the migrant crisis;
Strengthening fundamental rights and democracy
49. Is concerned that the cumulated crises have not only damaged the cohesion of European societies, but also shaken the faith of European citizens in their democratic institutions at EU and, in some cases, national levels; believes, therefore, that enhancing the EU’s democratic legitimacy and restoring the trust in its capacity to serve the interests of citizens must be Europe’s highest priority;
50. Recalls that many of today’s challenges – ranging from climate change to asylum and migration, from financial markets to multinational corporate firms, and from terrorist networks to failed and rogue states – are transnational and borderless, and require counterbalances and responses at their level; takes the view that the Commission should, to this end, encourage a renewed debate throughout society on what challenges people consider it most important to tackle at European level and where the EU should exercise ‘European sovereignty’;
51. Reminds the Commission that, as guardian of the Treaties, it must promote the general interest of the Union (Article 17 of the TEU), namely peace, its values and the well-being of its peoples (Article 3 of the TEU); calls on the commission to adopt the proposal for a regulation on open, efficient and independent European administration; notes that Parliament has a specific political responsibility to this end and needs to exert its institutional role fully and without self-complacency; considers that the recent setting-up of inquiry committees is an encouraging sign of Parliament taking its political responsibilities in terms of checks and balances more seriously;
52. Considers that the European Council’s tendency in recent years to resort to intergovernmental expedients jeopardises the ‘Community method’ and is in breach of the Treaties; recalls that, while under the Treaty of Lisbon members of the European Council are accountable individually to their own national parliaments but accountable collectively only to themselves, the national parliaments must be aware of their specific political responsibility to exert full democratic control over their representatives in the European Council;
53. Demands, given that non-transparent, one-sided lobbying poses a significant threat to policy-making and to the public interest, that all EU institutions strive for the highest possible standards of transparency, accountability and integrity, and relentlessly fight the tendency to overlook conflicts of interest, which is detrimental to the efficiency, fairness and reliability of the decision-making process; supports, in addition, a legislative proposal for the European-wide protection of whistleblowers in both the private and public sectors and reminds the Commission of Parliament’s repeated calls for this;
54. Asks the Commission to provide a comprehensive European response to the fundamental rights problems arising from widespread hate crime, hate speech, sexism, homophobia, transphobia and other forms of discrimination, including stepping up efforts to ensure that legislative proposals which will enhance social rights and fundamental rights are unblocked in the Council, in particular the 2008 proposal for a directive on implementing the principle of equal treatment between persons irrespective of religion or belief, disability, age or sexual orientation and the ‘women on boards’ directive;
55. Asks the Commission to take initiatives with a view to consolidating, strengthening and developing the means available to EU citizens to intervene in the political process beyond the electoral cycles; points out that this supposes increased transparency and public access to documents as well as greater support and resources for the EU Ombudsman, citizens’ petitions and a reform of the European Citizens’ Initiative regulation;
56. Considers that the Commission should put forward proposals for a mechanism for the protection of democracy, the rule of law and fundamental rights throughout the Union, by replacing its Rule of Law Framework with a more effective tool; believes that it should also continue to progress towards EU accession to the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), taking into account the Court of Justice opinion on the matter and addressing the remaining legal challenges;
57. Is committed to using all its tools and resources to act as a driving force in a renewed democratic process towards the reform of the European Union;
58. Demands that the Commission be confirmed as the negotiator with the United Kingdom on the Article 50 procedure;
59. Instructs its President to forward this resolution to the Commission.